Diplomacy?!
Oct. 12th, 2001 02:56 amHaving downloaded and viewed the "Diplomacy" Shockwave animation that so many seem to be raving about, I must admit I cannot share in the general enthusiasm.
Sure, the piece is technically well done (at least in terms of composition, pacing, sound, and so on) but I am... offended, I guess, by the "plot" of the story.
And I'm not sure exactly why. The story is puerile, but considering my past history, that's rarely been something that really bothers me. I suspect I'm bothered because the tactic adopted by the "peaceniks" in the animation is nearly identical to the efforts employed by the Soviet Union (and its allies) during the Cold War to undermine and weaken the will of the United States (the Paris peace talks come to mind, here).
That said, I have to ask: "So what?" If the events in the animation could be made to come to pass (as far-fetched as they are), would the outcome bother me? I think so.
I think part of my discomfort is the "St. Valentine's Day" ending. In the kind of world I want to live in, my side doesn't summarily shoot enemies who have thrown down their weapons.
Come to think of it, I think another component to the discomfort is the childish nature of the piece. The itch that this animation scratches isn't worth arousing.
Cheers...
Sure, the piece is technically well done (at least in terms of composition, pacing, sound, and so on) but I am... offended, I guess, by the "plot" of the story.
And I'm not sure exactly why. The story is puerile, but considering my past history, that's rarely been something that really bothers me. I suspect I'm bothered because the tactic adopted by the "peaceniks" in the animation is nearly identical to the efforts employed by the Soviet Union (and its allies) during the Cold War to undermine and weaken the will of the United States (the Paris peace talks come to mind, here).
That said, I have to ask: "So what?" If the events in the animation could be made to come to pass (as far-fetched as they are), would the outcome bother me? I think so.
I think part of my discomfort is the "St. Valentine's Day" ending. In the kind of world I want to live in, my side doesn't summarily shoot enemies who have thrown down their weapons.
Come to think of it, I think another component to the discomfort is the childish nature of the piece. The itch that this animation scratches isn't worth arousing.
Cheers...